On the Radar: Why the outlook for Canadian mortgage rates keeps shifting

  • First National Financial LP

Quick takes

  1. U.S. bond yields reversed their initial rise after this week’s inflation report as a technology-stock selloff increased demand for government bonds.
  2. Canada’s weaker employment picture supports the argument for rate relief, but Monday’s inflation report will help determine how much room the Bank of Canada has to respond.
  3. A sustained decline in Canadian five-year yields could improve new fixed mortgage offers before a policy cut, while existing prime-linked variable rates remain tied to lender prime.

The case for higher borrowing costs looked stronger when U.S. inflation accelerated this week. Within hours, the bond market was moving in the other direction. Selling in technology shares drew investors towards government bonds, reversing the initial rise in yields and extending the decline into Thursday.

For Canadian borrowers, the reversal complicates an already uncertain rate outlook. Weak domestic employment has strengthened the argument for relief, while inflation remains an obstacle. Global investors can nevertheless drive funding yields lower before the Bank of Canada reaches its next decision. This week showed how quickly the balance between those pressures can change.

Inflation pushed yields higher before markets reversed

Wednesday’s U.S. inflation report showed consumer prices rising 3.7% over the year to September, up from 3.4% in August. Prices increased 0.6% during the month. Gasoline accounted for more than half that monthly increase, but prices excluding food and energy also rose 0.3%.

The initial bond-market reaction was sharp. The U.S. 10-year Treasury yield climbed to approximately 5.33%, then retreated to around 5.19% by Wednesday’s close. During Thursday trading, it reached roughly 5.05%, about 14 basis points below the previous close.

The retreat did not require a better inflation report. As technology shares fell, investors sought the relative safety of government debt. Buying lifted bond prices and lowered yields, even though the inflation figures still presented a challenge for monetary policy.

That combination matters. Inflation can raise the return investors demand to hold bonds, while concern about equity valuations and economic growth can increase demand for those same bonds. A falling yield can therefore reflect greater unease about financial markets without signalling that inflation has been brought under control.

Canada faces its own inflation test

Last week’s Canadian employment report showed a loss of 68,000 jobs in September following August’s decline of 42,000. Public-sector employment fell by 70,000 in September, while private-sector employment was little changed. The composition makes it important to distinguish the weakness in the headline from a broad retreat in private hiring.

The Bank of Canada’s policy rate remains 2.25%, compared with the Fed’s target range of 3.75% to 4.00%. Canada’s employment losses strengthen the argument for supporting demand, but the Bank still needs to assess whether inflation permits an easier policy stance.

Canada’s September inflation report, due Monday, October 19, is the next domestic test ahead of the October 28 rate decision. Softer underlying inflation would make the case for relief more convincing. Persistent price pressure would make it harder to respond to employment weakness with lower rates.

By midday Thursday, Canadian five-year government bond yields were 3.54% and 10-year yields were 3.84%. Five-year Canada Mortgage Bonds yielded 3.64% earlier that morning, down from 3.70% the previous day. The decline offered some relief in mortgage funding markets, although better fixed-rate offers still depend on lenders passing through lower funding costs.

Fixed and variable rates can respond differently

For new five-year fixed mortgages, the relevant question is whether lower government yields translate into lower Canadian funding costs. A sustained decline in Canadian five-year yields can support better offers before any Bank of Canada cut. However, lenders also price their funding and credit spreads. If market stress makes that funding more expensive relative to government bonds, part of the benefit can disappear before it reaches borrowers.

Existing prime-linked variable mortgages respond through lender prime, which is closely influenced by the Bank of Canada’s policy rate. A rally in U.S. Treasuries alone does not reduce their interest cost. Existing fixed rates remain unchanged for their agreed term, while new commitments and renewals are exposed to the pricing available when rates are set.

Monday’s inflation report will help clarify the scope for Canadian policy relief. Meanwhile, fixed-rate offers could improve if lower bond yields translate into cheaper funding. This week’s reversal shows why that improvement can arrive before a policy cut, and why it may not last.